Why We Ask for SSNs
Collection of Social Security Numbers on Volunteer Applications.
- Will AYSO continue to require the SSN?
In the face of so much publicity these days about identity theft, more and more of our volunteers question why AYSO requires social security numbers (SSN) as part of the volunteer application process. Past AYSO President Joel Mark wrote the following memo in response to these concerns, and I have edited it to ensure it reflects our most current thinking and practices. We ask our volunteers to consider the following questions and answers concerning the AYSO decision to require the SSN.
Is this choice something that has been mandated unilaterally by the NSTC?
During the 1997 re-write of our Bylaws, which came from the floor of the NAGM and not from the National Office, some 750 Regional Commissioners, 75 Area Directors, 13 Section Directors, together with the National Board of Directors, voted unanimously to adopt Bylaw provision 1.04(t) to require all regions to "cooperate in the policies developed by the Board or the National Support [and Training] Center with respect to requiring each coach, referee and other designated volunteers to complete a volunteer form, and with respect to verifying the information obtained, before permitting such coach, referee or such volunteer to participate." This is what we - all of the Executive Members of AYSO - decided we must do because of our shared concern for children. This provision also is important for the health of the organization. Should AYSO ever be sued for not doing all it could to protect the children, we all would be liable for the damages a jury may assess because we are a unitary corporation.
Why does AYSO need the SSN in the first place?
AYSO is a national organization. ;We secure criminal background reports by searching court documents in county jurisdictions all across the country. These jurisdictions use a variety of personal information to identify those convicted of crimes. Unfortunately, there is no consistency as to the information used from jurisdiction to jurisdiction to identify those convicted. The expert opinions we sought and received on the matter told us unequivocally that all this information - including the SS# - was necessary to ensure the viability of the background information we secure. Collecting all this information serves AYSO on two fronts. First, the accuracy of the information we receive ensures that we exclude those with the highest potential for harm to our children, and, equally important, it helps us avoid excluding a good and valuable volunteer due to mistaken identity.
What risk do the volunteers face?
Experts have informed us that there are so many easier ways to obtain someone's SSN or otherwise engage in identity theft that it is extremely unlikely that giving the SSN to AYSO will significantly increase that risk. Things we put in our trash, leave in our car, or supply in connection with consumer, banking and insurance transactions, all contain the SSN or other information sufficient to make identity theft possible even without the SSN. Therefore, while identity theft is a real risk, AYSO has taken every possible step to minimize that risk. As a result ,we do not believe that supplying the SSN to AYSO increases the risk our volunteers otherwise may face regarding identity theft generally.
What risk do the children face?
Recent articles in the media have established that youth sports generally presents an increasingly enticing target for predators. It also is a tragic fact that, before our Safe Haven procedures were instituted, AYSO had documented incidents of child molestation by volunteers who turned out to be predators. Additionally, our Safe Haven procedures already have alerted us to a number of potential predators within our volunteer ranks. And, while it cannot be quantified, it is our strong belief that the Safe Haven procedures have deterred an additional number of other potential predators from applying as volunteers to AYSO. Thus, it seems quite clear that youth sports participants in the United States - including those who choose to participate in AYSO - unfortunately are at increased risk and would remain at such risk without some procedure such as Safe Haven to address and reduce that risk as far as may be reasonably possible.
What are the comparative consequences of the two risks?
While no one can calculate how many cases of identity theft AYSO may enable by collecting the SSN, if any, compared to how many cases of child molestation or abuse AYSO may prevent by doing so, we can measure a significant difference in the magnitude of the consequences. Experts have advised us that identity theft can be detected and corrected simply by running a personal credit check every year. And, while the most severe cases of identity theft may take longer to correct, they ultimately are correctable and good credit ultimately can be recovered. The same cannot be said for the child who becomes a victim of molestation or abuse. For the child who falls victim to such abuse, there is no cure except perhaps years of therapy and guilt and recrimination, years that can never be recovered.
How are these risks being addressed by AYSO?
Clearly, we need to do everything we can to reduce both risks. With respect to the children, every professional company with whom AYSO consulted about contracting to perform our background screening of volunteers informed us that, without the SSN, the accuracy of their reports could be diminished substantially. Therefore, AYSO has decided to heed this advice and require the SSN from volunteers to reduce the risk to the children. The risk to the volunteers of supplying the SSN can be and is being reduced significantly through our use of industry-standard encryption and certified electronic firewall's that protect the data stored on our servers. This is what AYSO has decided is the best balance between the two risks.
What has AYSO concluded it must do when a volunteer asks AYSO to choose between the risk to the children and the risk to the volunteer?
Admittedly, even the best devices and protocols cannot eliminate entirely either risk. Thus, some volunteers have asked AYSO to waive the requirement for the SSN - i.e., to choose between the two risks and to make the risk to the volunteers a greater priority than the risk to the children. We believe that AYSO must always stand up for the principle that, as between the two groups, it should never be the children who are put at increased risk. As a result, we have instructed all CVPAs to not accept a volunteer application from anyone refusing to fully cooperate with the process, including supplying the SSN. We know this may drive away some volunteers. But, we also know that it will drive down the risk that our children otherwise would face. We therefore remain convinced that, when asked to choose, AYSO must opt to put child protection ahead of the risk, if any, to a volunteer from supplying the SSN.
Will AYSO continue to require the SSN?
Until some other means of reliably verifying the information supplied by our volunteers becomes readily available we will continue to require the SSN to protect the children from unnecessary risk, to protect the organization from avoidable liability, and to comply with the Bylaw provision that the Executive Members have adopted unanimously. We respect that some people will refuse to supply their information. Regrettably, we will thank them for their interest but will not accept their application to be a volunteer in AYSO.
Thank you for giving your consideration to these important questions and answers attendant to AYSO's need to obtain volunteers' SSN. Should you have any further questions or concerns, please contact Rosemarie Banich at the AYSO National Office.